I'm a sucker for "bigger/brighter/louder" is always better. That's why -- as an increasingly dotty old codger -- I drive the biggest, baddest diesel truck I can afford to maintain, and I carry a handgun that has given me an arthritic hip.
In this spirit of excess, I just gave my one-year-old, semi-nuclear flashlight to my son, Scott, and I've purchased a new "torch," the EagleTac G25C2, which, when placed in "strobe mode," will induce epileptic seizures in anything with eyeballs: There's a cross-section of damaged rabbits, deer, elk and whatnot outside my bedroom window, even as we speak. It's dark, but I can see red eyes and lots of aimless milling around.
I think this thing cranks out about 800 lumens, which means nothing to me, except that it's a bigger number than the SureFire X300 (500 lumen) strapped to the bottom of my Glock's pistol frame, which was what I used to charge my Lum-Tecs with before the EagleTac arrived (removed from the COMPLETELY safety-checked, empty, pointed-in-safe-direction, Glock, of course).
The point is, you want something bright -- as close to old father "sol" as you can manage -- on a three-digit $ budget.
So, I point this thing at my SCB2 around 10PM (I'm up at 4:30 AM and doing important stuff in the garage...) and I give it a thirty second dose, which pretty much liquifies the lume. If my wife's around, I make sure she sees it. If not, it's the window and wildlife.
High intensity and short duration exposure is the formula. Think Hiroshima and/or Nagasaki, but without the collateral damage.